Monday, January 3. 2011What do infertile couples want most, a child or a pregnancy?Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
A good point, but I would also be cautious about dismissing the "genetic preference" too quickly. After all, one of the bases for the Church's teaching on reproductive technologies is the child's right to be naturally born to his real parents. We would object, for instance, to a scheme in which the natural relationship was totally rejected and babies were shuffled among parents before being sent home from the hospital.
This is not to denigrate adoption or to deny the real relationship between parents and adoptees. On the contrary, adoption, it seems to me, is a chance to redeem a fallen situation and bring those who otherwise wouldn't be in a family into one, somewhat analogous to our own redemption. In other words, instead of promoting adoption by dismissing the attractiveness of the natural "genetic" or "organic" family, I would praise adoption as a chance to bring a child into that natural relationship by an alternative means. Thus I think a better way to approach the IVF vs. adoption problem is to recognize that IVF is an expression of the same error that motivates abortion -- the desire to master and control nature, rather than accept it. Adoption is a far more reverent, humble and virtuous option. |
Follow or Contact me![]() marymeetsdolly [dot] com QuicksearchRecent Entries
ArchivesBlogs of Interest
Warning many of the following blogs are not Catholic or pro-life! My ears are burning..."great title, very informative site/blog" -- Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex "Cool blog! ...I like your honest and smart style..." -- Glenn McGee" "A must for every pro-lifer's bookmarks." -- Fr. Tim Finigan "really worth talking about" -- GOP Soccer Mom "She knows her stuff..." -- Spinal Confusion "a valuable resource" -- Amy Welborn "a must read for any Catholic or Medical Ethicist" -- Tomfoolery of a Seminarian "She's charitable AND loyal to the team. What a gal!" -- Amateur Catholics "For the love of little green apples!" -- Sailorette Categories |